Best bagels in Lawrence, NY — fresh, boiled, and baked daily.
Neighborhood rating
4.8 / 5
4 recent reviews
Ready in
12 min
Typical weekday pickup
Delivery
6 mi
South shore neighborhoods
The shop
Best bagels in Lawrence, NY — fresh, boiled, and baked daily. Come in for a toasted everything, send a dozen to the office, or build the sandwich the way you always do — online, in under a minute.
Pickup
Order ahead and walk to the counter.
Delivery
Within 6 miles of the shop.
Catering
24h notice for groups.
From the morning
Neighbors
4.8 average · 4 reviews
“Best bagels on the south shore — hands down. The healthy omelette is my go-to every Saturday morning. Fresh ingredients, fast service, and the staff always remembers my order.”
“The lox and cream cheese bagel is out of this world. We order catering platters for the office every Friday and it keeps the whole team happy. Reliable and always on time.”
“Finally a bagel shop that gets it right. Everything bagel, toasted, with scallion cream cheese — perfection. Love the online ordering, makes my morning commute so much easier.”
“Great neighborhood spot. Breakfast sandwiches are loaded and the coffee is solid. Delivery to Hewlett is quick. Only wish they were open a little later on weekends.”
Visit
Mon–Fri · 5:00 AM – 6:30 PM
Sat–Sun · 5:00 AM – 5:00 PM
10% off orders above $10 · code FOREVER10
Guest checkout. Full bagel modifiers. Ready texts only after the kitchen marks the ticket.
islandbagelbarny.com